The long awaited Thirty Meter Telescope draft EIS has been released. You would have to be asleep not to have heard by now, practically every island blog and newspaper has featured the EIS over the last day. It can be downloaded at the TMT EIS website, a mere 300+ pages and 54Mb.
I have not had a chance to read much of it yet, but an initial browsing reveals a favorable report. Give me a few days on that task of digging deeper into the document. I am on-call this weekend and must stick around the house. This will give me a chance to do a little reading and a little blogging between household chores and installing an irrigation system in the back yard for the fruit trees.
As usual, the fun part will not be the document itself, but the reaction from interested parties. I expect the usual screams from the hardcore astronomy opponents. And if experience is any guide, more than a little spinning or even outright distortions of the document. No matter how pragmatic or honest the document is, the opponents will see nothing but the worst.
As usual, my advice to anyone who has a stake in the subject, give the EIS a read and draw your own conclusions. We can then discuss the issue of the future of astronomy on Mauna Kea honestly and fairly.
There needed to be big changes:
We needed to make sure that the mountain was under the control of the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo. Mauna Kea is the kuleana of Big Islanders. It happened. A rule making bill passed through the legislature, which gave the University of Hawai‘i at Hilo enforcement powers to protect the mountain.
We agreed with Judge Hara that a Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) needed to be done. The CMP has been done. And, the last details are being worked on right now.
We’ve always agreed with others that $1/year rent was not acceptable. The draft EIS points out that there will be a community benefit package as well as a higher education package. In addition the TMT will sponsor a workforce development porgram, so todays 9th graders can be prepared to take jobs when the TMT is completed 9 years from now.
I know that a $1 million per year ($50 million over 50 years) education package for keiki from K-12 is doable as a start. The reason I know this --is because we have been talking about this very thing for many months.
The essential question is whether or not science and culture can coexist. Many, Many, of us believe that science and culture can indeed co exist–if it will benefit our keiki and future generations. This is a very traditional Hawaiian point of view.
Richard Ha