A kid standing beside Waikoloa Road with his thumb out. I hit the brakes and swing onto the shoulder a couple hundred feet past him as he runs to catch up. I clear out my junk from the passenger seat as we exchange pleasantries and start down the six miles to Waikoloa. I ask him how long he had been waiting, and the answer surprised me, an hour and a half!
A clean cut kid, lightly built, maybe 15 or 17, dressed in a clean T-Shirt with a backpack. Why did he have to wait so long for a ride? There is only one obvious reason, he was black.
To be sure, I also make that same decision when I see someone standing on the side of the road, do I want to pick up this person? Do they look respectable? Clean? Picking up a hitchhiker is a judgment, you are allowing someone you do not know into your space. This decision may be different for me, I am a large guy, few people intimidate me physically. I am male. Maybe my comfort zone is wider when letting someone into my vehicle.
But an hour and a half? How many cars passed this young man up on a busy afternoon? Not exactly the aloha spirit.
Most of the people I have given rides are just kids, trying to get to work, or get home. A cashier for the supermarket I shop at, a young gal working in a shaved ice shop, a lady who turned out to live on my street who's car was out of action. I will still make that judgment, but I suspect I will often hit the brakes.
I am glad however that we now have the free hele-on bus system and in-town shuttle buses.
Next we need a saddle road monorail.... that would really put us on the asia tourism map; I can hear the comments in Tokyo "Go to the Big Island it is like Disney World. " Plus it would provide that essential belt across the island and great fun!
I pretty much never picked-up HHs when I worked for the paper as I was concerned about liability should some kind of accident occur and I've always been concerned if all of a sudden a scanner calls sends me in the opposite direction to a fire or something similar.
I have stopped many times for stranded motorist who may need help with some car problems, have given a few a lift, jump started many cars, pushed many that were disabled to safety and stopped to render aid at accidents (even without shooting photos of said accident).
You're right, it's a judgement call.