While comet C/2012 S1 ISON is getting all of the attention, it is not the only comet currently visible. There are a couple other good comets available to observe or photograph. On Sunday morning I tracked down and photographed three comets.
The ZEQ25, TV-76mm and Canon 6D setup and taking photos of comet ISONComet ISON is sharing the stage with comet 2P/Encke and comet C/2013 R1 Lovejoy. All three are bright enough to be spotted in a small telescope. Encke was about magnitude 8, Lovejoy and ISON were both about magnitude 5 on Sunday morning.
Despite following comet ISON for the last year, I had never actually observed it myself. Attempts to change this repeatedly ran into problems, either work commitments or bad weather. Over the last month cloudy skies have been more common than clear, even the big ‘scopes on the mountain losing a large amount of time to poor conditions.
Another little lesson in astrophotography, one more in a very lengthy list… Do not use too short an exposure with the flat source.
Flat frames are used to calibrate out any uneven field illumination or dust in the field. This ever more important with the new camera, the larger, full frame sensor shows some vignetting at the corners. I use an electroluminescent source to do my flat frames, actually an old laptop back-light that has been re-housed in an acrylic frame. It provides an even illumination across the aperture of the telescope or lens I am using to acquire the flat field calibration frames.
A bad flat field taken at 1/4000 sec with the EL back-light flicker interacting with the camera shutterWhat I have discovered is that the EL backlight flickers. This is too fast to see with the eye, but if the camera exposure is fast enough it will create issues. This shows up as horizontal structure across the field as the flicker interacts with the camera shutter.
I discovered the effect as I took flats the first time with the Canon 6D. I had the ISO set to 6400 which resulted in a 1/4000 sec exposure. Fortunately I looked at the last flat and saw the problem before I dismounted the camera from the telescope, it was pretty obvious. Once the optical setup is disturbed it is not possible to re-shoot the calibration frames.
A proper flat field calibration frame, Canon 6D and AT6RC telescope.It took a few seconds of thought to realize what the problem was. I never realized an EL light flickers, or rather I had never thought about it. Given that EL lights are driven with a high voltage switching power supply, flicker should be expected. The switching frequency of the supply should be above the human threshold of hearing to avoid an annoying whine, at least 20kHz. It can not be too much higher than that or it would not have shown up in a 1/4000 second exposure.
Slowing the camera down removes the effect. As I could not change the aperture I simply reduced the ISO to minimum, this slowed the shutter speed to 1/15 of a second for the nice mid-scale exposure needed for flats.
The corrected flats reveal the usual things that a flat is takes to correct. The dark corners reveal the expected uneven field illumination. the dust doughnut reveals at least one notable speck of dust on the cover glass of the sensor. There is a dark band at the bottom of the frame which I believe to be shadowing from the edge of the mirror. Looking at the flat I realize I will need to be conscientious about taking flats with the Canon 6D.
I had set the alarm clock for 0230 to get up with plenty of time to setup and take comet photos. What greeted me was a sheet of cloud, an all to familiar sight lately. I did not reset the alarm and went back to sleep. A couple hours later I found myself lying awake again, realizing I would probably not fall back to sleep I got up to look outside. To my surprise Orion shown brightly over the street.
Is there enough time to setup and shoot before dawn?
I rushed the alignment, hoping to setup in less than half an hour. Things did not go smoothly… The EOS utility in the computer did not recognize the 6D, I need to update the drivers. A thin cloud stubbornly sat in front of Polaris, I think I got the polar alignment, the star was very dim on the polar ‘scope. Even when exposures seemed to be going smoothly I they were not. I find out later the auto-guider had moved itself to a hot pixel, probably when a bit of cloud passed through. In the rush I did not get a dark frame for the guider, most of the frames show small guide errors.
One not so bad bit of serendipity… The Hubble Space Telescope went right through one of the frames.
Despite all I did get an image of the comet. It should have been better, rushing astrophotography is not a good plan…
Comet C/2013 R1 Lovejoy on Nov 15, 2013. Canon 6D with the AT6RC and a 0.8x focal reducer. 12 x 60s at ISO 6400.
Yes, the 6D on a telescope! Just getting things setup for some possible comet shooting. The clouds over Hawai’i may actually be breaking up after a week of very wet weather.
A 94% illuminated waxing Moon, Canon 6D and AT6RC with 0.8x focal reducer.
After our comet ISON observing session I have been asked what it is like to take a comet photograph with Keck. An apt question as all of the recent observers were taking spectra, not photos.
Comets are big. While the nucleus is quite small, we do not see the nucleus even with the enormous power of a 10 meter telescope. It is hidden in the coma and quite dark, the average nucleus is a shade of dark gray equivalent to charcoal.
The coma and tail are very extended, much larger than the field of view of the telescope, thus the entire frame is inside the coma. The photo of Hartley 2 Greg and I took was no exception.. The image is notable for its complete lack of any interesting structure. There are no jets, shells or other inner coma detail visible. The tail is simply a general brightening to the southwest (lower right in this image).
Small telescopes, in the hands of amateurs, are going to produce the prettiest images of comets. With fields of view measured in degrees, not arcminutes, the comet is going to be seen in all its glory.
Comet 103P Hartley 2 with Keck2 and DEIMOS 6Oct2010 @ 7:27UT, 3x60s, 3x60s and 3x120s with standard BVR astrometric filters, credit: Cooper/Wirth/W.M. Keck Observatory
I will probably make my first attempt to photograph C/2012 S1 ISON this coming weekend. A couple reasons for waiting… The bright Moon will have moved out of the morning sky by then. The comet, currently around magnitude ten, is brightening rapidly.
On the other hand the comet is plunging towards the Sun, rising later each day. Wait much longer and the photographic opportunity will slip away, at least until after Thanksgiving, when the comet will again appear after perihelion.
In the meantime, one of my favorite comet photos from years past…
Comet C/2007 N3 Lulin on the morning of 22 Feb 2009
The Iris Nebula, NGC7023, in Cepheus, image taken at Oregon Star Party 2013, 10x60s+10x240s+10x480s TV76 and Canon 60D on a ZEQ25 mount and STi autoguider
